DO-IT-YOURSELF WEB SITES THE PROS AND CONS


Not sure what's involved in getting a web site started? Well,
there are really only three ways to go about it. In this article,
I'll provide an objective review of the strengths and weaknesses
of each approach.

(a) The DIY solution: Create and maintain your web site yourself

by using software such as Microsoft FrontPage or by writing

the HTML directly.

(b) The half-n-half solution: Have an external party create the

web site. You then do the regular updating of the site

yourself.

(c) The full outsourcing solution: Have an external party create

and update the site.

(a) THE DIY SOLUTION

ADVANTAGES

This is the cheapest solution. You don't need to pay any fees

to consultants.

If you enjoy being creative this could be an enjoyable and

rewarding activity.

You'll have complete control over your web site's "look and

feel."

There's no chance of a consultant handing you a site that

isn't what you wanted.

DISADVANTAGES

DIY sites often look amateurish. This can turn away customers.

DIY sites often have poor navigation controls. In a

well-designed site, the user should be able to find what they

want in seconds. Achieving this is not as easy as it sounds.

You'll need to obtain some suitable software and then spend

time learning how to use it perhaps a lot of time.

You will need to learn the arcane secrets of effective META

tags, JPEG compression, browser compatibility, FTP clients,

loading speed and more if you want the site to perform well.

SKILLS NEEDED

Patience: This will all take time.

Good PC skills; e.g. a familiarity with both text and graphics

applications.

Technical skills or the willingness to acquire them.

Graphic design and page-layout skills.

(b) THE HALF-N-HALF SOLUTION

ADVANTAGES

You'll need far less technical knowledge.

The graphic design, page layout and navigation elements of the

site will all be done for you thus avoiding many of the pitfalls

that strike amateur designs.

A consultant will probably produce the site faster than you can.

If you have the skills (and the desire) to update the site

yourself, this may be the best trade-off between price, speed

and professionality.

DISADVANTAGES

You'll still need to have (or learn) some technical skills, but

not nearly as many as with the DIY solution.

Consultant's cost may be hundreds of dollars even for a small

site. Larger sites will cost more, of course.

You run the risk of the consultant not providing the design

that you were looking for.

Major changes or upgrades to the site will probably need to be

done by the consultant.

When you update the site yourself you risk "breaking" something

or just "messing it up."

SKILLS NEEDED

Some technical skills or a willingness to acquire them.

The ability to liaise with the consultant about how you want

the site to look and what you want it to achieve.

(c) THE FULL OUTSOURCING SOLUTION

ADVANTAGES

You are not required to spend time and effort learning

technical skills that other folk already know and (let's be

honest here) can probably do better.

This requires the least effort on your part.

A consultant will produce the site faster than you can.

This should produce a professional looking site that navigates

easily, loads quickly, is compatible with all browsers and

works well with search engines.

DISADVANTAGES

This is the most costly solution.

You have less control over the content of the site.

SKILLS NEEDED

The ability to liaise with the consultant about how you want

the site to look and what you want it to achieve.

CONCLUSIONS
Choosing between these solutions comes down to two main issues:
your budget and your skills. If you have the skills needed (and
the free time), you can save yourself hundreds of dollars in
consultants' fees. If not, consider bringing in a consultant to
design the site for you and, perhaps, to do the updates as well.

About the Author

Tim North
info@scribe.com.au
http://www.scribe.com.au/ebooks.htm